Some perspective on industry certifications
I recently had an interesting discussion about the value of information security certifications, like CISSP, CISA, etc. The person I was talking to believed that commercial pressures would eventually make any such certification valueless. In this conversation I learned about the existence of on-line churches that will ordain you as a minister if you fill out a form on their web site. In many cases there's not even a fee for doing this.
Intrigued by this, I found the web site of one of these organizations and submitted a request to be ordained. I got an email almost immediately addressing me as "Reverend Martin" and welcoming me to the ranks of ordained ministers:
Congratulations! You are now a legally ordained minister for life, though you may relinquish your credentials at any time. AS OF Wednesday the 17th of February 2010 YOU HAVE BECOME A MEMBER OF THE PRESTIGIOUS CLERGY. You have earned a title worthy of admiration and respect.
The web site of the organization that ordained me claims that I'm now allowed to do things like baptisms, funerals and marriages. For only $30 this organization will even sell you a certificate that's apparently good enough to convince government officials of some states that you're a legitimate minister. They even sell a product called "Ministry-in-a-Box," but at $139.99, it's way more than I can afford.
I'm sure that there are some people who get ordained on-line who take their responsibilities as a minister very seriously, but there are probably just as many who don't. But because there's no way to easily tell which one a particular minister is, those certificates that you can get for $30 don't really tell you anything useful. All they tell you is that the person listed on it filled in a form on a web page and then spent $30 on a certificate.
I hope that industry certifications like the CISSP and the CISA don't end up being as devalued as credentials for ministers seem to be now. But because there are now lots of competing certification programs for information security professionals, I wouldn't be surprised if the standards for certifications do indeed loosen up over time.
(I haven't actually done any baptisms, funerals or marriages yet, but I have to admit that I'm less likely to swear now, even when editing standards documents or working on the paperwork for our FIPS 140-2 validation. I'll definitely have to relinquish my credentials, though, when we start our next Common Criteria evaluation.)